Review: Acer Aspire One Laptop
Share |
Reviewed by Ryan Knaus on 10/16/2008
Editors' rating: 0.0/10
Detailed editors' rating
Average user rating:
GD Star Rating
loading...
See all user reviews
GD Star Rating
loading...
Bottom Line

This is an Acer Aspire One ultra-portable ‘netbook’ with an 8.9″ screen. It is the 120GB, Windows XP version and the color is Sapphire Blue

The specifications include:

  • Intel Atom Processor N270 (1.6Ghz) with Windows XP Home Edition
  • 1GB DDR2-533 RAM
  • 120GB 5,400RPM Hard Drive
  • Intel Graphics Media Accelerator 950
  • Acer InviLink 802.11b/g Wi-Fi CERTFIED Wireless Network
  • 8.9″ WSVGA CrystalBrite Display
  • Size: 9.75″ x 6.625″ x 1.28″
  • Weight: 2.19 lbs
  • 3-cell battery

Reasons for Buying

I bought this computer for its extraordinary portability and functionality. I work online and needed a laptop that I could quickly check and then tuck away into a backpack. The new Asus EEE 901 got pretty good reviews, but its nearly $600 price tag was too much for me. The Acer Aspire One cost a good deal less and got high marks for its build quality and keyboard, making my decision pretty simple.

Where and How Purchased

I originally purchased the Solid-State Drive with Linux Lite (Linpus) from Amazon.com, but exchanged it before opening. I am unfamiliar with Linux and really just wanted a miniature clone of my home computer — so for my purposes, sticking with Windows was the right choice. Many users have complained that the SSD is too slow, and there were inexplicably two different manufacturers of Aspire One SSD drives…so already I was wary of the SSD version. Then there was the size of the hard drive — 120GB for the XP version, compared to a mere 8GB for the Linux.

After I settled on the 120GB, there was the matter of locating one — Amazon wasn’t shipping new units for four-to-six weeks, and I couldn’t wait that long. The only other retailer that had the XP model available was Microcenter.com. They are somewhat notorious for not having a live inventory system, which frequently leads to back-orders, cancellations, etc. In this case, however, I lucked out by placing an order soon after a new shipment arrived. They even had the ‘Sapphire Blue’ version, which is what I wanted (good luck finding pink or brown in the U.S.). The final cost, including shipping, was $419.00. More than I wanted to spend (the 8GB SSD cost only $349), but worth every penny.

Build & Design

The Aspire One has a very simple, elegant design. It features a glossy screen and a glossy shell, both of which are pretty but prone to smudging and collecting fingerprints. I was thrilled that the blue version was in stock, because you can’t even tell if it has smudges across it. I read multiple reviews that described the Asus EEE netbooks as flimsy, but the Aspire One has no such problems. The hinge is made of sturdy plastic and silver metal with a ring of red anodized metal around it…very nice from a practical and aesthetic point of view. It also opens to (my rough guess) a 150 degree angle.

Acer.JPG

Acer.JPG

It weighs 2.19 pounds, and is so light and small that I sometimes check the internet while walking. The tiny size does not make it a nuisance to balance on your lap. It is so small and sturdy that unless you live on an active fault-line, ‘wobbling’ is never an issue. The screen has pretty decent protection, and it took a good deal of force on the back of the screen before ripples were evident. For such a small and light computer, it is remarkably well built.

Screen

The screen has surprising clarity and brightness. I frequently use it outside, in conjunction with wireless broadband, and it fares pretty well. Unfortunately it is glossy rather than matte, so on bright, sunny park benches I find myself hunched over and squinting as I hold the screen in my own shadow.

I haven’t seen a single dead pixel, and I’m thrilled with the quality of the screen — although I will rarely use it for multimedia, it looks great playing back video files with WinDVD. On full brightness in a dark room, I can’t notice any light leakage around the edges. The screen has average viewing angles from the left and right, though it is harder to see from above and below. The computer is so tiny, however, that it is easy to adjust for a proper viewing angle.

DSCN3638.JPG

DSCN3638.JPG

Speakers

The speaker, singular, is ridiculously bad. On top of the poor quality (in fairness, it must be tiny), it is located underneath the computer, further muffling the sound. Adequate for system alerts and the occasional YouTube video, but basically useless for listening to music. Fortunately, headphones exist! The quality is great when heard through headphones or external speakers, so pack a pair of earbuds.

Processor and Performance

The Aspire One comes with the Intel Atom N270 running at 1.6Ghz. I frequently use internet, RSS Owl and word processing simultaneously, and it still responds very quickly. Occasionally when running a bunch of tabs in Internet Explorer 7 the computer does slow down, but even that happens only when the RSS reader refreshes its 200+ feeds.

Booting up takes about 50 seconds…not terrific, especially compared to the 15-second boot-up time for the Linux version, but sufficient for my needs. The hard drive runs at 5400 RPM, and it reads and writes perfectly well. As I mentioned earlier, some users complain about slow speeds in the SSD Aspire One’s, so I was happy to avoid that possibility.

I play no games on this computer, so I can’t offer much in the way of a recommendation. Maybe the benchmarks below will shed light on that aspect of the Aspire One.

Benchmarks

PCMark05: I was first asked to install Windows Media Encoder 9, which I did. Then it said there were errors and would not produce any results (N/A). Not sure what that means, but it didn’t seem to reflect well on my Aspire One’s processing speed.

Super Pi: Calculated two million digits in three minutes and 28 seconds.

HD Tune: Hitachi HTS543212L9A Benchmark
Transfer Rate Minimum : 27.8 MB/sec
Transfer Rate Maximum : 52.4 MB/sec
Transfer Rate Average : 42.0 MB/sec
Access Time : 17.8 ms
Burst Rate : 78.6 MB/sec
CPU Usage : 3.8%
Temperature was a steady 40 degrees Celsius.

Heat and Noise

One of the Acer Aspire One’s strong suits is that it is very cool and quiet, thanks largely to the Intel Atom processor. You can park it on your lap for hours without heat being an issue, and the fan –though running almost continuously– is so quiet that I rarely notice it at all. The lack of an optical drive eases the fans’ already meager duties.

Keyboard and Touchpad

The keyboard and touchpad are worlds apart, in terms of functionality. The keyboard is great, for such a small computer. While smaller than a full-sized keyboard, I found it surprisingly easy to adjust to the reduced layout. I have large hands, and occasionally hit the wrong key, or two keys at once, but it is acceptable for normal use. I wouldn’t recommend writing research papers, but it is ideal for sending out a quick email or chatting on AIM. There is a bit of flex in the keys, but they are springy and give a nice tactile response to each keystroke. One very trivial complaint, I wish there were buttons for Volume up/down and Brightness up/down, rather than having those controls as functions of the arrow keys.

The touchpad, on the other hand, is somewhat poorly designed. The pad itself is fine — it is smooth and responsive, and the screen is so small that it can be easily navigated with a few strokes. Unfortunately, the left and right buttons are located on either side of the touchpad. This saves ¼ inch in overall width, but it makes one-handed surfing a real chore, and you need to contort your fingers to select text or drag-and-drop. The buttons are also unreasonably loud — if you need a reassuring ‘click’ every time you click something, then you are the target audience. I have a wrist problem and I use a wireless USB controller with mouse and keyboard mapping, so I rarely use the touchpad, otherwise it would frustrate me much more.

00Acer overview.JPG

00Acer overview.JPG

keyboard.JPG

keyboard.JPG

Input and Output Ports

This is a computer built for ease of use, portability and connectivity. As such, it sports a nice array of connections for such a tiny CPU:
(1) VGA 15-pin Port, (3) USB 2.0 “A” Ports, (1) RJ-45 Network Port, (1) Microphone Port, (1) Headphone Port, (1) Multi-in-1 card reader, (1) SD card reader, a microphone and a webcam.

00Acer right side.JPG

00Acer right side.JPG

00Acer left side.JPG

00Acer left side.JPG

Wireless

The Aspire One comes wit h the Acer InviLink 802.11b/g Wi-Fi card. It works beautifully, picking up all of the same local wi-fi networks as my other computers (an HP and a Mac). One notable omission is Bluetooth capability, which would have been a very nice touch.

Battery

This is one gripe I have with the Aspire One — the standard 3-cell battery lasts an average of 2 ½ hours (with wi-fi turned on). The new model Asus EEE 901 packs a six-cell battery and lasts around 6-7 hours — what a huge difference that would be! For a computer designed to be on the road, packed away and popped out in train stations, buses, etc…it would be logical to include a larger battery supply. The “battery-sipping” Atom processor does what it can, but ultimately you might decide (as I have) to purchase a separate six-cell battery. Sadly, it costs about $120 bucks, nearly 1/3 the price of the computer. Supposedly Acer has a model that comes with a six-cell, but I could not find it in stock at any U.S. retailer, online or otherwise. Also, I read that the six-cell battery juts out further than the three-cell, preventing the computer from being stored in the slip-cover that Acer ships with each Aspire One. I guess if you’re dropping $120 on a battery, $20 for a new cover wouldn’t be a deal-breaker.

Operating System and Software

The computer ships with Windows XP SP3, but did not include restore discs. As explained in more detail below, Acer has some sort of recovery program built into the CPU, though I believe it partitions 15GB of your hard drive (wish I knew more about this aspect, can someone provide more details in the comments section?)

The software included was sufficient without being cumbersome (HP could learn from Acer in this regard). The “trial version” of Microsoft Office 2007 comes included, though I immediately uninstalled it in favor of OpenOffice. The lack of an optical drive simply means you’ll need to scour the internet for certain drivers and programs that you would otherwise install via CD or DVD…or you can hook up an external drive via USB, etc. WinDVD come installed, which is a nice easy way to watch a huge variety of video formats. Acer keeps the branded products and programs to a minimum. I dumped McAfee in favor of OneCare — I’m not sure which is better, but OneCare seems to interrupt me far less frequently, and runs fewer background processes, from what I can tell (though I could be very wrong). This computer comes loaded with everything I needed, from a software and hardware standpoint.

Customer Support

The initial user experience was disappointing for one reason only — XP glitched upon loading, giving me an error message and continually re-booting without ever moving past the XP splash screen. I called Acer support and within 30 minutes (after hitting Alt + F10 repeatedly during boot-up) the computer was running normally. Unfortunately (I could be wrong about this, but I don’t think so) the steps they led me through partitioned 15GB worth of my hard-drive, so instead of 120GB, I essentially started with 105. I only need enough music and pictures to load on my 30GB Zune, so the lost space didn’t bother me. There is a one-year limited warranty from Acer, and it did not cost extra.

Pros:

Light weight, small size
Solid construction
Bright, good-quality screen
Very nice reduced-size keyboard
Speedy, cool and quiet

Cons:

Small screen
Lousy speaker
Awkward touchpad layout
Lack of Bluetooth
Short battery life

JusTech'n editors' rating
Features0/10
Design0/10
Performance0/10
Warranty0/10
Support0/10
Price0/10
0.0/10
Related Posts:

7 Comments

  • Anomalovaho says:

    should have gone with the LINUX VERSION, IT’S REAL KOOL

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • Love my Aspire One says:

    You can see more detailed information about the partition sized on your system by doing this:
    -Right Click on My Computer
    -Select Manage
    -Click on Drive Management on the left
    -Click on C: drive in the right hand side window
    -View below and see how large the partitions are on your drive.

    My restoration partition is 4.88GB

    So far, this thing is rocking! I am using it in class, in a silent room the fan can be heard, but other than that I don’t even notice it.

    Plugged in a mouse and external monitor when at home for bigger work, it is a very versatile ‘does most things anyone would need to do’ portable.

    Definitely will be getting the 6 cell battery but other than that, I have no complaints.

    In my experience and opinion, you can’t go wrong for an XP netbook. Got mine at Walmart for $298, just awesome.

    I love Linux and have Ubuntu on here now too, but too many old apps or special software won’t install quite right in WINE.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • I hate it!!! It is slow,slow,slow…This is my first and last Acer… After hearing so many positive reviews from my friends etc…on other Acers. I am just upset that Acer would sell this piece of crap at any price.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • agreed….mine is a hunk of crap too, the music stutters, it’s takes a few MINUTES to boot up, i can’t have more that 2 tabs up without it glitching, and the noise it makes when you plug something in plays randomly….even when i am away from it.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
  • This system is absolutely awesome.
    First, I suggest cleaning up some of the extra apps that are stuck on it.
    Second, I took the effort to pull out the 512Mb stick and put in a 1Gb in its place. That makes a ton of difference, but it is something that you want to do only if you are confident enough with a good handful of screws and about 20-30 minutes of focus. Otherwise, find someone who will do it for you.
    Third, realize that when you unplug the power the processor speed drops in half for power saving. There are apps out there that will allow you to bypass that when you want.
    It is not a desktop replacement, but with a little bit of effort, it can run almost anything short of resource heavy games.
    It is a netbook, it is portable and convenient, bump up the RAM and ditch the extra apps and it will rock.

    GD Star Rating
    loading...
    • steve w says:

      which apps and how-i have the aspire one 150 with 160 gig and 1gig of ram?
      steve waldman

      GD Star Rating
      loading...
      • Steve W,

        I got rid of the MS Office Trial, McAfee, anything that I didn’t have an immediate need for. Google Chrome runs amazingly fast on here too.
        I ran msconfig and looked at the items that automatically started up and evaluated whether I needed them and turned their auto-starting off either there or in the actual programs themselves.
        Defrag once the system is cleaned out.
        The program I use to control hardware/fan/webcam/screen settings is a1ctl: http://nodadev.wordpress.com
        You can turn off the LAN, wifi, webcam to save power. Change the processor to or from 800MHz or Dynamic mode… Control what temp the fans turn on etc. Read up on it, it is essential for XP.
        I also took another step and dual booted it with the Ubuntu Netbook Remix. It is running absolutely smoothly and damn quick with no adjustments needed.
        That is how I am using mine.. if you need anything else just let me know.

        GD Star Rating
        loading...

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is in use. Please do not submit your comment twice -- it will appear shortly.

Click here to go to the forum for this post